Pour a cup of coffee, I went long with this post.
The Cardinals, led now by John Mozeliak, made their first roster management move recently when they removed Cody Haerther from the 40-man roster and saw him snatched up by the Toronot Blue Jays, raising some eyebrows. This reduced the number of players protected for the December 6 Rule 5 Draft to 35. That list is here:
| |
Number and Name |
Bats/Throws |
| 1 |
29 Chris Carpenter |
R/R |
| 2 |
63 Andy Cavazos |
R/R |
| 3 |
60 Brian Falkenborg |
R/R |
| 4 |
34 Randy Flores |
L/L |
| 5 |
31 Ryan Franklin |
R/R |
| 6 |
77 Blake Hawksworth |
R/R |
| 7 |
44 Jason Isringhausen |
R/R |
| 8 |
56 Kelvin Jimenez |
R/R |
| 9 |
19 Tyler Johnson |
S/L |
| 10 |
52 Josh Kinney |
R/R |
| 11 |
41 Braden Looper |
R/R |
| 12 |
30 Mark Mulder |
L/L |
| 13 |
35 Joel Pineiro |
R/R |
| 14 |
23 Anthony Reyes |
R/R |
| 15 |
36 Russ Springer |
R/R |
| 16 |
48 Brad Thompson |
R/R |
| 17 |
50 Adam Wainwright |
R/R |
| 18 |
37 Todd Wellemeyer |
R/R |
| 19 |
4 Yadier Molina |
R/R |
| 20 |
62 Brian Barden |
R/R |
| 21 |
7 Adam Kennedy |
L/R |
| 22 |
12 Aaron Miles |
S/R |
| 23 |
5 Albert Pujols |
R/R |
| 24 |
27 Scott Rolen |
R/R |
| 25 |
13 Brendan Ryan |
R/R |
| 26 |
26 Scott Spiezio |
S/R |
| 27 |
24 Rick Ankiel |
L/L |
| 28 |
16 Chris Duncan |
L/R |
| 29 |
15 Jim Edmonds |
L/L |
| 30 |
43 Juan Encarnacion |
R/R |
| 31 |
47 Ryan Ludwick |
R/L |
| 32 |
– Joe Mather |
R/R |
| 33 |
53 John Rodriguez |
L/L |
| 34 |
55 Skip Schumaker |
L/R |
| 35 |
99 So Taguchi |
R/R |
| 36 |
|
|
| 37 |
|
|
| 38 |
|
|
| 39 |
|
|
| 40 |
|
|
The Cardinals have a number of players who may draw interest in the Rule 5 Draft coming up:
- Jason Motte, the hard throwing catcher-turned pitcher.
- Jarrett Hoffpauir, the 2nd baseman with excellent plate discipline.
- Stuart Pomeranz, the 6’7″ RHSP who was nearly impossible to score upon in the AFL in spite of an inability to strike batters out. He missed most of the 2007 season to injuries.
- Mike Parisi, a RHSP who’s probably safe left unprotected, but may draw attention from any teams more desperate for durable-looking fifth starters than the Cardinals, if such a team exists.
- Kyle McClellan, a local product who put it all together last season in relief.
- Mark Worrell, another reliever with a lovely strikeout rate.
- Mike Sillman, a reliever who probably didn’t pitch enough last year to draw serious consideration from other teams.
- Matt Scherer might attract a few teams.
That’s five players that I’d guess we’d want to add to the 40-man roster and thus protect from the Rule 5 draft: Hoffpauir, Motte, Pomeranz, McClellan, and Worrell.
Some may ask, wouldn’t it have been easier to cut Andy Cavazos or Kelvin Jimenez from the 40-man instead of Haerther in order to open up the desired five roster spots? Or just DFA Taguchi, since he’ll be non-tendered six days after the Rule-5 draft anyway, after his option was bought out a week or two ago? And it seems likely to me that the time has come to part ways with Aaron Miles, if only to further shake up the middle infield that’s been a problem the past season.
I’m guessing they’ve got some plans for making waiver claims and perhaps a Rule 5 draft pick that they need more roster flexibility for. Maybe they’ve got a trade in the works that they need roster space for before December 6th. It wouldn’t surprise me if Cavazos and Jimenez are both cut in the next few weeks as well. The timing is strange—you’d have liked to see a trade worked out. I, for one, am not a big believer in Haerther like many of the projection systems, but would be happy to see him produce for the Blue Rays and crush the Yankees on a routine basis.
Let’s say the Cardinals plan to add those five players mentioned before, which would bring the total for now to 40, with opportunity to open up to four more roster spaces by parting with any of Miles, Taguchi, Cavazos, and Jimenez. They need to add a “number two starting pitcher” by trade and at minimum, a shortstop to compete for playing time at short with Brendan Ryan.
I hope that I’ve made clear my belief that the only starting pitcher possibly available by trade who could turn out to be #2 quality this season and who could be acquired without destroying the farm system is Mike Hampton, who threw a successful bullpen session the other day and is scheduled to start a game in the Mexican Winter League on Tuesday. (The boxscore will be up here after the game.) The Braves rounded out the front three of their rotation tonight by signing Tom Glavine for $8M. That’s $14M for Smoltz, $13M for Hudson, and $8M for Glavine in the front three—$35 million clams for the arithmetically challenged. They’d have Hampton at $8M and four cost-controlled options {Jurrjens, James, Carlyle, Reyes} for the last two spots, so I’d have to think Hampton could be available. For what it’s worth, they’re supposedly looking for a backup middle-infielder, someone with MLB experience to compete with newly acquired Josh Anderson to keep center field warm for a year or two. I hate trade proposals like this, but what if So Taguchi, Aaron Miles, and Jason Motte could get it done. Not sure why they wouldn’t just use Lillibridge as the backup MI, so the Miles suggestion shouldn’t be taken too seriously. The Twins already traded for Monroe, who would’ve been available after the non-tender deadline, so why not Taguchi and Miles, right? Right? I’d imagine Bruce Manno would have nice things to say about Taguchi, who’s already making $100,000 from the buyout. Maybe someone will think that Miles could do better when not overexposed like he was with the Cardinals.
I’ve mentioned Zobrist as a candidate for short, borrowing an idea from Azruavatar. He’s either real bad, below average, or slightly slightly above average defensively at short, depending on who you ask, and was an on-base machine as a minor-leaguer. I’m thinking he may become available via waiver. The Devil Rays need to cut down to a 24-man roster since becoming a hockey team. They have 39 men on the 40-man right now. Quickly scanning the peripherals of some of their unprotected minor leaguers who are eligible for the Rule 5 draft turns up eight players that the Rays will have to risk losing:
- John Jaso, a super catching prospect who would be a might nice backup next season, and who will certainly be protected
- Fernando Perez, a speedy outfielder with great on-base skills who looks like a nice lead-off man
- Jason Pridie, an outfielder who put up a very nice line in 2007 and who was taken by the Twins in the Rule 5 draft last season
- Dale Thayer, a relief pitcher who dominated at AA and AAA (although with an unsustainably low .231 BABIP)
- James Houser, a big RHSP with pretty nice peripherals
- Reliever Evan Meek
- Michael Prochaska, a lefty starter who gets ground balls
- Nick DeBarr, a big RHRP with extreme groundball tendencies.
I’d guess keeping at least one of those non-Jaso players in the organization will be end up being more valuable to Tampa Bay than waiting for Zobrist to adjust to the majors and he’ll be available by trade or on waivers. If you pick up Zobrist on or before rosters are set, you can safely non-tender Miles and have an improved team. I’d hope Mo keeps in touch with the Rays’ GM over the next few weeks.