John Mozeliak didn’t ask my opinion, but I feel strangely compelled to give it anyway.
The top priority for the offseason is apparently picking up type-A LHRP Brian Fuentes to close for the Cardinals in 2009. Fuentes is a very good pitcher who can get both righties and lefties out. He’s a three-time all-star. He’d also likely lose the closer role at some point during the season as he had in 2007 with Colorado. He’d prefer to pitch for the Angels, where I wouldn’t be surprised to see Scot Shields take over as closer.
The poop on the street is that Fuentes wants something in the area of 3/$33M.
I don’t want the Cardinals to sign Brian Fuentes. Too much money, too many years on the arm, too costly losing the first-round pick. I’m well aware that our bullpen last year had problems. We need another good lefthander: we’ve got Trever Miller on a very team-friendly contract. I’d like to see Dennys Reyes pitching for the Cardinals next year to solidify the left side of the ‘pen. Reyes is a type-B FA who was offered arbitration, so the Twins will get a sandwich pick when he signs, but the team signing him won’t lose anything. He wants a three-year deal, as does Fuentes, but Reyes is two years younger and is a (very good) LOOGY, not a closer, so the year-to-year cost wouldn’t be terribly high. (I’ve had an eye on Reyes since the 2006 season, when the Ricardo Rincon era ended prematurely.
There aren’t any established closers available on the FA market, unless you count Trevor Hoffman or Eric Gagne. It may sound a little hypocritical, seeing as he’s also a type-A FA who was offered arbitration, but I could see good things coming from signing Juan Cruz to a three-year contract at setup man rates, something in the neighborhood of 3/$12M, maybe more given the crappy Farnsworth signing. The downside to that is that you lose your first-round pick in the ’09 draft, of course, and also the ex-Cubs factor he brings. The upside is that he’s developed into a very good strikeout pitcher, a plague on the houses of all left-handed hitters, and is three years younger than Fuentes. In fact, he’s been one of the best relief pitchers in baseball over the past two years, striking out over 12 batters/9 over that span and putting up an ERA+ of 176 in 2009. That in spite of pitching half his games in the second most hitter-friendly stadium in the major leagues.
I suggest we sign Juan Cruz to a contract similar to the one we picked up Braden Looper on going into ’06 with incentives for IP targets. Juan Cruz starts out 2008 closing until, ideally, Perez is clearly ready for the ninth inning. Then Cruz moves into a set-up role or takes Piñiero’s spot in the rotation if Carpenter hasn’t already. (I suppose it’s a remote possibility that Jo-el could improve from last year, but I don’t see it happening.) Cruz profiles pretty similarly to Wellemeyer—hard thrower, good minor-league history as a starter, struggles at the major league level due to walks that landed him in relief. If he could put up a 3.68 FIP as a starter in 2009 and 2010, he’d almost certainly be worth the first rounder. (That’d require him to maintain the 0.87 HR/9, drop his BB/9 to 3, and keep his K/9 from going below 8.)
Another reason I’d like the Cardinals to sign Juan Cruz is that I’d very much like Ben Sheets to be a Cardinals in 2009 without giving the Brewers an absolutely knock-out draft next summer. The market looks spooked by the flexor muscle tear near the elbow that Sheets endured late last season, but I’m a believer that Sheets’ injury history is more flukiness than frailty. If the Cardinals sign both Cruz and Sheets, our first-round pick goes to Arizona and the Brewers get our second round pick for Sheets, since Cruz is ranked 16th among free agents by Elias, while Sheets comes in at 23. I’ve heard 2/$30M being bandied about for Sheets, with a lot of teams looking to cut payroll this off-season, I could see something even less. Over the next two years, Carp will be making 28.5 million, so that’s about the limit that I expect the Cardinals would be willing to offer.
Pretty much sacrifice next year’s draft (although you’ll always find some talent that’s unexpectedly dropped to the third round) and put together a great team without helping out the competition too much.
So here’s how I’d like to see our roster work itself out for next year:
Rotation
- Wagonmaker
- Sheets
- Wellemeyer
- Lohse
- Piñiero/Carpenter
Bullpen
- Cruz RHRP (CL)
- Perez RHRP
- Motte RHRP
- K-Mac RHRP
- Franklin/Kinney/Wonderbrad RHRP
- Reyes LHRP
- Miller LHRP
Starting Lineup
- C: Molina R
- 1B: El Hombre R
- 2B: Kennedy L
- 3B: Glaus R
- SS: Spicoli R
- LF: C-Dunc L
- CF: Ankiel L
- RF: Ludwick R
Bench
- C: LaRue R
- OF: Schumaker
- OF: Barton/Mather/RazzleDazzle
- IF: 2 of Brian Barden/Brenden Ryan/David Freese
Going off the most recent Roster Matrix at VeB, the payroll for that team would come in at around $111 million. They’d look like contenders on paper: if everything breaks right—healthy Carp and Sheets, resurgent Kennedy and Greene, solid bullpen, they’d be an excellent baseball team. With the Cubs planning on spending around $143M, we’d be fielding a comparably talented team without shooting ourselves in the foot for the future.
Go get ‘em, Mo.
Update/Correction: This is what I get for trusting ESPN, I guess. According to USA Today’s reporting on the Elias rankings, Ben Sheets scores a 79.038 on the FA list; Juan Cruz is lower at 76.627… The rankings are the same as reported on ESPN, sort of: Sheets is 23rd among NL pitchers and Cruz is 16th among NL relievers. I have to imagine that FA’s are lumped together, though. If you sign a starter and a reliever, both type As, whichever one scores higher should be considered the bigger loss by the old team, not whichever one happens to be ranked higher within his positional category. Bummer. I was wrong. It would’ve been nice to dramatically improve our team without providing the Brewers with our first-rounder.


